Skip to main content

In the e-commerce logistics world, competition is fierce. Consumers are getting more selective about purchases as the number of available sources to purchase items increases. They can easily compare prices, quality, and more to narrow in on the specific place they'll make a purchase. And if your business has done its job and won the customer's business, the last thing you want to have happen is to have that customer get to the checkout only to abandon their cart once they see the shipping charges.

But at the same time, you also need to ensure that you're making enough profit to make your business viable. It is a business after all and that's the goal of a business.

So what should you do?

Make selecting an appropriate shipping strategy a top priority for your company so that you're able to achieve a proper balance between keeping customers happy (and minimizing shipping charge related cart abandonment) and protecting your profit margins. In this blog post, we'll provide an overview of the three most common strategies used by e-commerce businesses and the pros and cons of each.

Variable Rate Shipping

This shipping strategy works exactly as it sounds—shipping prices vary by order depending on what customers purchase, how far away they are and how quickly they need the item. Typically this shipping strategy relies on an in-checkout shipping calculator that provides fields for customers to fill in. They are then given the shipping cost based on the data they entered.

Why this strategy works is two-fold:

  • Transparency builds trust: Customers can see that what they're paying for shipping is based on actual, tangible information (like their location, item weight, etc.) so they'll see you're not inflating shipping charges for extra profit. Instead, you're simply charging the going rate for shipping that item.
  • Protection for your margins: It ensures that you don't end up taking a financial hit for large, heavy, or bulky items—where factors like DIM pricing can push costs up—as the customer will pay what you'll pay.

Free Shipping

Nothing beats the marketability of free shipping, we all know that. Customers love that they can have the convenience of ordering an item online and still paying what they would pay for it in a store. This is a surefire way to minimize abandoned carts for shipping-fee shy customers. However, depending on the products you sell it can be difficult to cover the costs of free shipping.

Large or heavy items will be more costly to ship—especially once accessorial charges are factored in—and if you offer free shipping you might be limiting the amount of profit you can make. You can get around this in a couple ways:

  • Increase your prices to offset some of the shipping cost (a customer is less likely to notice an item is slightly more expensive than they are a shipping fee)
  • Offer free shipping on orders over a certain amount. This way you can better control the balance between profit and shipping costs you cover.

Flat Rate Shipping

This type of shipping strategy can be done in one of two ways:

  • One flat rate for all packages (usually ground shipping with an increase for expedited shipping times)
  • Multiple flat rates for certain ranges like weight or order total

In order for this strategy to work you need to do some initial legwork to analyze the shipping costs of your average orders to select a price that doesn't over or undercharge customers. However, once you have the rates in place it makes it easy for both you and customers and leaves no room for confusion or second-guessing on shipping charges.

This strategy works well with customers who don't need items particularly quickly because they'll be able to choose the lowest cost shipping for their items, which feels like a win for them. And it works well for a business because they've put in the work to know that the shipping charges are high enough to maintain healthy profits.

Final Thoughts

Once you have a thorough understanding of each of these potential shipping strategies you can take the time to analyze your current product offerings, your customer base's preferences, and your desired profits to determine which strategy makes the most sense. Each has its benefits but only one will give provide your business with the optimal balance between happy customers and reasonable shipping costs. Here at LTX Solutions, we have worked with all of our e-commerce customers on their shipping strategies and what works best for them and their customers. If you aren't sure which strategy is best for you, or how to implement it, contact us and we're happy to help!

FAQs

What is the best ecommerce shipping strategy for avoiding cart abandonment?

There is no single best ecommerce shipping strategy, but the right one is usually the one that balances customer experience with profit margin. Variable rate shipping can reduce cart abandonment by showing charges upfront, free shipping can be highly attractive to shoppers, and flat rate shipping keeps pricing simple. The best choice depends on your products, customers, and cost structure.

How does variable rate shipping work for ecommerce orders?

Variable rate shipping sets the shipping price based on the specific order, including the customer’s location, item weight, and delivery speed. It often uses an in-checkout shipping calculator so shoppers can enter their information and see the cost before buying. This approach helps make shipping charges feel transparent and protects margins on larger or heavier items.

Why do ecommerce businesses offer free shipping if it cuts into profit?

Ecommerce businesses offer free shipping because it can reduce shipping-related cart abandonment and make online checkout feel more appealing. To keep margins healthy, businesses often either build some shipping cost into product prices or offer free shipping only on orders over a certain amount. That way, the business can control costs instead of absorbing them on every order.

What is flat rate shipping in ecommerce?

Flat rate shipping means customers pay a set shipping charge instead of a variable one. It can be one flat rate for all packages, often with a higher charge for expedited delivery, or multiple flat rates based on weight or order total. It works best when the business has already analyzed average shipping costs and set rates that avoid undercharging.

When should an ecommerce business use flat rate shipping instead of free shipping?

Flat rate shipping is a good fit when you want predictable pricing for both the business and the customer, especially if shoppers are not in a hurry and prefer a simple low-cost option. It is often easier to manage than free shipping when product weights and shipping costs vary, because you can set rates that still protect profit margins.

How do accessorial charges and DIM pricing affect ecommerce shipping costs?

Accessorial charges and DIM pricing can increase shipping costs, especially for large, heavy, or bulky items. DIM pricing can make a package cost more to ship based on its size rather than just its weight, while accessorial charges add extra fees for certain handling conditions. Both can make free shipping harder to sustain without raising prices or adjusting thresholds.

How do you choose the right ecommerce shipping strategy for your business?

You choose the right ecommerce shipping strategy by reviewing your product mix, customer expectations, and target profit margins. Businesses should compare how variable rate, free shipping, and flat rate shipping affect checkout behavior and overall cost. The best option is the one that fits your average order profile and keeps shipping charges realistic for your operation.